The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes show's poster

The Superfluous Finger

This series brings to life the many detectives of late Victorian London who were "The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes," from R. Austin Freeman’s brilliant forensic expert Dr. John Thorndyke to Arthur Morrison’s notorious villain, private inquiry agent Horace Dorrington, William Hope Hodgson’s world-famous ghost hunter Carnacki and Baroness Orczy’s detective Lady Molly of Scotland Yard.

RMPBS Passport

Please log in to your PBS Passport account to watch this video

Become a Member

The Superfluous Finger

Season 2 Episode 7 | 50m 31s | CC

When a beautiful young woman asks a London surgeon to cut off one of her perfectly healthy fingers, there must surely be an intriguing reason for this. Jacques Futrelle’s Prof. van Dusen is called upon to “think” his way to a solution.

The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes

Watch more episodes

See more
See more